Published by the 50/50 by 2030 Foundation, University of Canberra

Research and Stories through a Gendered Lens

#MillionsMissing – Gender bias adds to the burden of disease

May 11, 2019 | News

ME/CFS affects millions of people around the world with devastating impacts. The disease is not well understood, leaving sufferers ‘missing from their own lives’. As patient and advocate, Jen Brae, notes in her popular Ted Talk, because of ME/CFS there are “ballet dancers who can’t dance, accountants who can’t add, medical students who never became doctors”. For this reason advocacy events are connected with the hashtag #MillionsMissing.

People with ME/CFS have the lowest quality of life compared with those suffering from more than 20 other diseases

ME/CFS is a complex neurological disease that affects all the major systems in the body including the endocrine, cardiac, gastrointestinal, and endocrine systems. While it is not rare – in Australia it is estimated up to 250,000 people suffer from the disease – there are no known causes, effective treatments or cure. People with ME/CFS have the lowest quality of life compared with those suffering from more than 20 other diseases including multiple sclerosiscancer, diabetes, stroke, kidney failure and schizophrenia. Twenty five percent of those affected are either bedbound or housebound. More than 75% of those with ME/CFS are women. 

It is common for ME/CFS patients to be misdiagnosed with psychiatric conditions. A brand new study found that 42% of those who went to an emergency department were dismissed as having psychosomatic complaints. One of the most common of these misdiagnoses is conversion disorder. Once known as hysteria, it was a common label doctors placed on women in the Victorian era who were considered overly emotional. However, the current diagnostic criteria for conversion disorder requires that no other condition (including ME/CFS) would explain the neurological symptoms. 

In ’Doing Harm,’ Maya Dusenbury shows how people with ME/CFS suffer from a paradoxical gender bias in healthcare. Women’s symptoms aren’t taken seriously because medicine doesn’t know as much about their bodies and the diseases that affect them; and medicine doesn’t know as much about women’s bodies and the diseases that affect them because it doesn’t take their symptoms seriously.

shutterstock 350895047

The gender bias in medicine affects women in a range of situations. Heart attacks are the biggest killer of women in Australia but are half as likely to receive appropriate testing and treatment upon presentation to a hospital. Women are also likely to be referred for cardiac rehabilitation and prescribed preventive medications upon discharge. Women are less likely than men to get CPR from a bystander if they collapse on the street and are more likely to die. Although women make up two thirds of Alzheimer’s patients, researchers have found that in the UK, women with dementia receive worse medical treatment than men with the condition

Women’s pain is taken less seriously than men’s, and they experience longer diagnostic delays for everything from brain tumours to rare genetic disorders. Before the invention of ibuprofen, doctors used to regularly tell patients that period pain was in their heads. One in ten Australian women suffer from endometriosis at some point in their life, but it can take from 7-12 years to get a diagnosis

Systematic bias has significant flow on effects for patients, their families and the community at large. Current figures show a record number of sick and disabled people are on Newstart, having been denied access to the Disability Support Pension. Not only does this reduce the income patients have to cover the basics like housing, but it also means they are unlikely to have the budget to cover medical expenses such as visits to doctors or specialists, prescriptions or supplementary medication that may help manage their symptoms.  

Government programs like the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) have policies based on outdated research claiming that people with ME/CFS get better with the Cognitive Behaviour Therapy and Graduated Exercise Therapy. The research for these treatments has been thoroughly disproved and it has been shown how Graded Exercise Therapy in fact makes patients worse. Yet, patients are still being rejected from the NDIS either because they haven’t ‘exhausted all known treatment options’ or because their condition is not considered ‘permanent’, two criteria used for determining eligibility.  

After being rejected for the NDIS, an appeal can be lodged with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The bureaucratic burden of applications and appeals is extreme, especially for people who are already restricted by disease and disability. While the government and medical systems in Australia remain unchanged, patients who suffer from this disease remain the #MillionsMissing from their everyday lives. 

 

+ posts

Susan Hutchinson is an activist scholar with expertise in women, peace and security and civil-military interaction. She is the architect of the prosecute; don't perpetrate campaign to help end impunity for conflict related sexual violence and is undertaking a part-time PhD at the AUstralian National University on the operationalisation of the suite of UN Security Council resolutions on Women, Peace and Security. Her professional background is aid and development NGOs, government, and the military.

Highlighted article

Other highlighted articles

When women vote, reason trumps rage

When women vote, reason trumps rage

A hundred or so years ago, there was a woman called Vida Goldstein. She was an internationally renowned suffragist. She was the first Australian in the oval office. She ran as an independent several times because she was so independent, that she couldn’t bring herself...

Online data could be used against people seeking abortions

Online data could be used against people seeking abortions

When the draft of a Supreme Court decision that would overturn Roe v. Wade was leaked to the press, many of us who have been studying privacy for vulnerable individuals came to a troubling realization: The marginalized and vulnerable populations whose online risks...

‘The effects of this toxic industry are everywhere’

‘The effects of this toxic industry are everywhere’

Content notification: This post discusses sexual violence and trauma.  'Body Shell Girl' is a memoir in verse about the first two years of a decade that Australian Rose Hunter spent in the sex industry in Canada. Rose hoped she could do only what was required of her,...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This