Published by the Faculty of Business, Government and Law, University of Canberra

BroadAgenda

Research and Stories through a Gendered Lens

Economic inequality: The parallel realities of men and women

Oct 14, 2018 | News

Written by Mark Kenny

Caren Grown’s description of a stubbornly impervious gender imbalance within all domestic economies, once again prompts us to think of what must be done to unlock wealth and opportunity for roughly half of the world’s population.

The World Bank Group’s Senior Director for Gender lamented the universal failure of economies to seriously close the gender pay gap despite big gains for women in other areas like health and education.

 … burgeoning global attention to the issues have barely moved the needle on access to wealth and power

This is timely given a widening acceptance that good intentions, legislative changes, and burgeoning global attention to the issues have barely moved the needle on access to wealth and power.

 She noted for example that somewhere in the neighbourhood of $160 trillion globally is lost to potential growth due to women’s economic exclusion.

shutterstock 404211841

 Enlightened governments and progressively inclined corporations understand this and have introduced various programs in recent years. But the problem of parallel realities for men and women persists.

 A powerful mix of political and cultural forces, buttressed by doctrinal economic arguments, ensure that quotas designed to mandate a minimum proportion of women in management, board, and governmental leadership positions remain off-limits. Standard operating procedure is to pillory quotas as social engineering, presenting them as market distorting interference in free commerce.

 Amazingly given the damning statistics, official-level denial of the need for serious structural re-adjustment proceeds from an a priori assessment of long-run market functionality. This is neither empirically nor subjectively evident.

 Rather, Dr Grown’s work, and that of many others, reveals that it is worse than demonstrably wrong, in that it condemns the future to the underperformance of the past.

  “Women only account for about 38% of global human capital wealth, whereas men account for about 62%”

shutterstock 614747969

“When you sex-disaggregate the data, it’s pretty astounding. Women only account for about 38% of global human capital wealth, whereas men account for about 62%,” she said during a talk at the 50-50 by 2030 Foundation with Virginia Haussegger.

fullsizeoutput 16b2

… a neo-liberal insistence that rules-based remedial measures (quotas) are anathema, is not merely a failure of political representation, but pointedly, of markets themselves

The oil-and-water existence of long-term structural disadvantage of women in economic participation, and a neo-liberal insistence that rules-based remedial measures (quotas) are anathema, is not merely a failure of political representation, but pointedly, of markets themselves.

 Indeed, we may even go further and propose that such resistance represents a betrayal of free market function by protecting the most egregious market distortion of all, that of culturally legitimated discrimination in production and consumption – for no better reason than ‘twas ever thus.

 Rather than apologising for quotas as regrettably necessary, their introduction might better be presented as the removal of a distortion? 

Viewing it this way raises an enticing question. Could it be that reframing this culturally entrenched discrimination to expose its tension with free market economic orthodoxy offers a way forward – a new language for redress, based on the predominant neo-liberal lexicon of power?

 Rather than apologising for quotas as regrettably necessary, their introduction might better be presented as the removal of a distortion? A correction for dysfunctional labour and product markets which has locked out a whole class of market participants, ensuring growth is always less than it could be.

Highlighted article

Other highlighted articles

Recognising diverse perspectives in environmental accounting

Recognising diverse perspectives in environmental accounting

Have you ever heard of the concept “what gets measured, gets managed”? It means that when we put a value on something, people are more likely to pay attention to it. This approach is traditionally used in business settings but has become increasingly relevant for...

What Sam Mostyn’s appointment as Governor General means

What Sam Mostyn’s appointment as Governor General means

This morning we woke to the news that Sam Mostyn will be the next Governor General of Australia. Since the announcement, I’ve been wading through emails and social media posts celebrating the appointment. I agree with all of them, but I’ve been struggling to...

Dreaming of a life in politics? Apply now!

Dreaming of a life in politics? Apply now!

UC program paving the way to greater female political representation It’s 2023 and nineteen women find themselves standing on the steps of Old Parliament House. They don’t share a cultural background or come from the same age bracket. They don’t even share the same...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This