Diversity without quotas? Reflections of a Liberal MLA

in Opinion , Tagged Australia, Politics, The Liberal party, quotas.
  • Lee biography

    Elizabeth Lee

    Canberra Liberals

    Canberra based Elizabeth Lee MLA was elected to the ACT Legislative Assembly in October 2016. She is Assistant Speaker, Shadow Minister for Disability, Shadow Minister for the Environment and Member for Kurrajong.

republish

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence.

Opinion:

The ACT Government recently held its first Gender Equity Forum: The Case for Change. It may be Australia's smallest juristriction, but on a national scale, the ACT punches above its weight when it comes to gender equality. Even without the introduction of gender quotas, it is  the only political jurisdiction to crack the 50/50 target, with 52 percent of seats held by women.



Yet, when it comes to gender quotas not only are Australian political parties divided, so too are the generations! And not along the lines you might presume. In the nation's biggest state the NSW Liberals are considering a 40 percent quota for women, which reportedly has caused a "massive stoush" with the NSW Young Liberals, who reject the idea.

 



For a young, Liberal woman's view on quotas we turned to rising Liberal star Elizabeth Lee MLA. Canberra based Lee was elected to the ACT Legislative Assembly in 2016, and already she's touted as a potential party leader and Liberal Chief Minister.



Read her frank response below. (Photo: The Canberra Times, Elizabeth Lee 2016)


There is no doubt that in 2017, Australia has some way to go to improve representation of women in leadership roles – whether that be in politics or in other fields.

The issue of quotas comes up from time to time and certainly as a political weapon used by Labor and Greens to attack the Liberals about the number of women members elected into Parliament. And, to be fair, Labor and Greens do have a greater representation of women amongst their elected members.

Elizabeth Lee Car 2 660 1

Elizabeth Lee campaign 2016

Like with a lot of issues of equity, inclusion and diversity, there is no easy answer in attaining gender equity. If there was, surely we would have solved this already!

Any and every idea to improve representation of women in politics is worth exploring.

The biggest issue I have with quotas, however, is this: if we set quotas for women in politics, what is the reason for not having quotas for other "groups" (I guess I can't really say "minority groups" now given the latest ABS stats shows that there are more women than men)?

... if we set quotas for women in politics, what is the reason for not having quotas for other "groups"

The make-up of our parliaments (at federal and at State/Territory levels) should, as much as possible, broadly reflect the diversity of the community that we serve. And this is why it's so important to have about half women elected members. But what about our Indigenous Australians? Our non-Anglo Australians? Our LGBTIQ Australians? Will we start to see quotas for all? And if not, why not?

My party can and should do better on this issue

I am the first to say that, as a Liberal, my party can and should do better on this issue and I am personally engaging with young Liberal women at the university and Young Liberals level to encourage, mentor and make influential roles in the party more accessible to them.

liberalwomen

It's no secret that the Liberal Party does not have a quota. The Canberra Liberals certainly doesn't.

What we do have, however, is a Party Room that is half women. Out of the 11 Canberra Liberals members, we currently have five women and six men. This make up is likely to go to six women and five men depending on who is elected on a count back after Member for Kurrajong Steve Doszpot announced his retirement this month.

The diversity of our Party Room was not achieved by quotas

 

And what we do have is a Party Room that includes a number of members from cultural backgrounds other than Anglo-Australian. Our Party Room’s diversity stands in stark contrast to the members from the Labor and Greens’ which is extraordinarily homogenous.

The diversity of our Party Room was not achieved by quotas. This was achieved by elected members (men and women) identifying, encouraging and supporting good women candidates.

This was achieved by creating a party culture that values achievements and contributions by all Canberrans, whatever their background or experience.

We can all do more to achieve gender equity. This is not just a “women’s” issue left for just women to champion. This is an issue of diversity, equality and, more importantly, it is a matter of what is best for our community.

And that impacts all of us.

Post your comment

Comments

  • julie 17/11/2017 4:05pm (5 days ago)

    Quotas unashamedly exist for 'factions' in both Liberal and Labor parties, for Nationals in the coalition, for rural, regional distributions. ACT is also represented at Federal level on a quota system - 2 from each house - all of this to ensure democratic representative spread across population - "share of spoils" if you were

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments